Another Poor Showing But United Advances at Southampton (01.29.11)

Hello,

First off, a comment about the press.  I love how practically every footy press channel talked about Southampton's famous 1976 Wembley win over United.  That was the year I was born.  The pundits kept saying:  "could Southampton revive 1976?".  While I can see that the press need to pump up games, this analogy is silly.  Personally, I only compare the last two years to see if there are any threats to United.  Spirit and belief of a 1976 win will not be the reason for a win nor defeat in 2011. 

Second, let us talk about the two worst performances perhaps of the year:  Gibson and Anderson.  While United's midfield is struggling in general, I was ready to strangle Gibson.  I have no idea how you can put on a United jersey and not close down players, especially from a League 1 side.  Gibson is slow, not very creative and cannot seem to get a string of 2-3 consecutive passes.  Similar for Anderson with respect to putting on a United jersey and playing so poorly.  I made a joke about the hairdryer coming out at half time and Bill Blair said something I agree with:  "why should these players need it?  This is Manchester United".  Agreed Bill.  Also, their poor play affects other players like Scholes and especially the left sided defenders.  I sometimes wonder what Scholes, a legend and creative genius, thinks of these younger player's performance, especially up against much lower opponents.  Games against League 1 opponents should be viewed as a test by the manager.  Well, Gibson and Anderson, you failed.  Have a look at 37-year old Giggs.  He closes down players, makes runs and passes.

Third, sloppy goals.  While the Saints' goal was largely due to Gibson and Anderson (in my opinion), United's goals were basically broken down plays and not necessarily due to great set-ups or goals.  The first United goal, scored by Owen, was a broken down play and probably a hand ball by the Saint defender.  The second goal was another broken down play but credit to Hernandez for the finish.

United has a tendency to make it difficult on themselves by playing an open style of football.  Today, while they did play open style, it was the tactics that caused issues, a goal and lack of dominate first half possession, it was terrible play by two players that caused disruption in the flow.  You know who you are.

While Chelsea bought Torres, I was hoping United would by a five star attacking mid-fielder.

No such luck.

Next up for United, at Old Trafford, is non-league side Crawley Town.  If you were a Crawley Town fan, would you want the real Red Devils or someone you have a shot at beating?  That said, they will cash in on gate money. 

See you soon for more FA Cup and Champions League spots.

Derek